{"icon":{"sha256":"a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741","relativePath":"icons/a8/a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741.jpg","extension":"jpg","mediaType":"image/jpeg","width":50,"height":50,"byteLength":1580,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"animationMetadataInspectedUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:10.2585053+00:00","scannerMetadataVersion":1,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:10.2585063+00:00"},"observations":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","sourceDisplayName":"Prospect live gallery www.propublica.org","sourceKind":"static-gallery","sourceType":"prospect-queue","rightsProfile":"Unreviewed prospect; preserve provenance and review rights before redistribution.","originalUrl":"https://www.propublica.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/julia-angwin-1000x1000.jpg?w=50","downloadUrl":"https://www.propublica.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/julia-angwin-1000x1000.jpg?w=50","pageUrl":"https://www.propublica.org/people/julia-angwin","title":"Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race — ProPublica","altText":"","categoryPath":"article / facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race / facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","status":"accepted","observedUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:10.2593647+00:00"}],"sourceTags":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"article","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race — propublica","evidence":"observation · title · gallery · observation-title","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"julia angwin 1000x1000","evidence":"observation · file-name · gallery · observation-download-url","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"julia angwin 1000x1000","evidence":"observation · file-name · gallery · observation-original-url","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"reviews":[{"id":635054,"runId":63,"model":"qwen3-vl:30b","promptVariant":"wordwall-v1","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-smart","enrichmentMetadataVersion":5,"description":"Pixelated portrait of a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses and a dark top against a light blue background.","rawJson":"{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741\",\"description\":\"Pixelated portrait of a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses and a dark top against a light blue background.\",\"denseCaption\":\"The image is a pixelated portrait showing a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses, and a dark-colored top. The background is a light blue gradient. The person\\u0027s face is centered in the frame with a neutral expression. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance typical of early digital photography. Visible details include the person\\u0027s ears, nose, mouth, and the texture of the skin. The lighting appears even across the face.\",\"wordwall\":[\"pixelated portrait\",\"short dark hair\",\"dark-framed glasses\",\"dark top\",\"light blue background\",\"neutral expression\",\"low-resolution\",\"blocky appearance\",\"even lighting\",\"centered face\"],\"visibleText\":[],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"person\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[],\"colors\":[\"dark brown\",\"light blue\",\"beige\",\"dark gray\"],\"style\":[\"pixelated\",\"low-resolution\",\"portrait\"],\"composition\":[\"centered face\",\"medium close-up\",\"even lighting\"],\"mood\":[\"neutral\"],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[\"image appears upscaled from lower resolution\"],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[\"observation category (gallery): article\",\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race\",\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica\",\"observation title (gallery): Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race \\u2014 ProPublica\",\"observation file-name (gallery): julia-angwin-1000x1000\"],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race\",\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica\",\"observation title (gallery): Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race \\u2014 ProPublica\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[\"julia-angwin\"],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"pixelated portrait dark hair glasses\",\"low-resolution blue background neutral expression\",\"dark-framed glasses light blue background\",\"centered face pixelated portrait\"],\"uncertainty\":[],\"aestheticStrengths\":[],\"aestheticWeaknesses\":[],\"tags\":[{\"tag\":\"person\",\"category\":\"subject\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: person\"},{\"tag\":\"pixelated\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: pixelated\"},{\"tag\":\"low resolution\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: low-resolution\"},{\"tag\":\"portrait\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: portrait\"},{\"tag\":\"neutral\",\"category\":\"mood\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: neutral\"},{\"tag\":\"dark brown\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: dark brown\"},{\"tag\":\"light blue\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: light blue\"},{\"tag\":\"beige\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: beige\"},{\"tag\":\"dark gray\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: dark gray\"}],\"rawModelResponse\":{\"icons\":[{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741\",\"description\":\"Pixelated portrait of a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses and a dark top against a light blue background.\",\"denseCaption\":\"The image is a pixelated portrait showing a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses, and a dark-colored top. The background is a light blue gradient. The person\\u0027s face is centered in the frame with a neutral expression. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance typical of early digital photography. Visible details include the person\\u0027s ears, nose, mouth, and the texture of the skin. The lighting appears even across the face.\",\"wordwall\":[\"pixelated portrait\",\"short dark hair\",\"dark-framed glasses\",\"dark top\",\"light blue background\",\"neutral expression\",\"low-resolution\",\"blocky appearance\",\"even lighting\",\"centered face\"],\"visibleText\":[],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"person\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[],\"colors\":[\"dark brown\",\"light blue\",\"beige\",\"dark gray\"],\"style\":[\"pixelated\",\"low-resolution\",\"portrait\"],\"composition\":[\"centered face\",\"medium close-up\",\"even lighting\"],\"mood\":[\"neutral\"],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[\"image appears upscaled from lower resolution\"],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[\"observation category (gallery): article\",\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race\",\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica\",\"observation title (gallery): Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race \\u2014 ProPublica\",\"observation file-name (gallery): julia-angwin-1000x1000\"],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race\",\"observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica\",\"observation title (gallery): Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race \\u2014 ProPublica\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[\"julia-angwin\"],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"pixelated portrait dark hair glasses\",\"low-resolution blue background neutral expression\",\"dark-framed glasses light blue background\",\"centered face pixelated portrait\"],\"tags\":[]}]}}","requestId":"1440e9d9115b45ae8fd5ae0609ea24a3","promptTokens":1935,"responseTokens":623,"totalDurationNanoseconds":2879148100,"elapsedMilliseconds":6127,"reviewedUtc":"2026-08-21T06:24:00.3060927+00:00","tags":[{"tag":"beige","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: beige"},{"tag":"dark brown","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: dark brown"},{"tag":"dark gray","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: dark gray"},{"tag":"light blue","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: light blue"},{"tag":"neutral","category":"mood","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: neutral"},{"tag":"low resolution","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: low-resolution"},{"tag":"pixelated","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: pixelated"},{"tag":"portrait","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: portrait"},{"tag":"person","category":"subject","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: person"}],"facts":{"colors":["dark brown","light blue","beige","dark gray"],"composition":["centered face","medium close-up","even lighting"],"denseCaption":["The image is a pixelated portrait showing a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses, and a dark-colored top. The background is a light blue gradient. The person's face is centered in the frame with a neutral expression. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance typical of early digital photography. Visible details include the person's ears, nose, mouth, and the texture of the skin. The lighting appears even across the face."],"description":["Pixelated portrait of a person with short dark hair, wearing dark-framed glasses and a dark top against a light blue background."],"metadataNotConfirmedByImage":["observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","observation title (gallery): Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race — ProPublica"],"metadataOnlyEntities":["julia-angwin"],"mood":["neutral"],"nonRedundantSearchPhrases":["pixelated portrait dark hair glasses","low-resolution blue background neutral expression","dark-framed glasses light blue background","centered face pixelated portrait"],"preprocessingNotes":["image appears upscaled from lower resolution"],"sourceMetadataInterpretation":["observation category (gallery): article","observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","observation category (gallery): facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","observation title (gallery): Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race — ProPublica","observation file-name (gallery): julia-angwin-1000x1000"],"style":["pixelated","low-resolution","portrait"],"subjects":["person"],"wordwall":["pixelated portrait","short dark hair","dark-framed glasses","dark top","light blue background","neutral expression","low-resolution","blocky appearance","even lighting","centered face"]}}],"duplicateCluster":{"groupId":1695864,"canonicalSha256":"a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741","duplicateBasis":"singleton","members":[{"sha256":"a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741","relativePath":"icons/a8/a8da55c09a900d642aaa210ac4a81d619a5f2c6ef27d57bdb051b3a87ba18741.jpg","extension":"jpg","mediaType":"image/jpeg","width":50,"height":50,"byteLength":1580,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:10.2585063+00:00","matchBasis":"canonical","matchDistance":0,"qualityScore":86.567372,"isCanonical":true}]},"canonicalPath":"/icon/facebook-lets-advertisers-exclude-users-by-race-propublica--a8da55c09a900d64","tagCounts":{},"typedEvidence":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004331,"value":"article","normalizedValue":"article","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004331,"value":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","normalizedValue":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004331,"value":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","normalizedValue":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004331,"value":"julia-angwin-1000x1000","normalizedValue":"julia angwin 1000x1000","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-original-url","disposition":"search","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004331,"value":"julia-angwin-1000x1000","normalizedValue":"julia angwin 1000x1000","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-download-url","disposition":"search","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004331,"value":"Facebook Lets Advertisers Exclude Users by Race — ProPublica","normalizedValue":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race — propublica","scope":"observation","kind":"title","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-title","disposition":"search","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"contentSafety":[{"id":766657,"runId":1255,"provider":"onnx","model":"OwenElliott/image-safety-classifier-s","task":"broad","inputMode":"image","preprocessMode":"four-even-frames;flatten-rgb192;stretch-224;triangle;nchw-rgb-u8","overallScore":0.09353212267160416,"overallLabel":"sfw","assessedUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:10.3531043+00:00","scores":[{"category":"onnx/sfw","score":0.9064679145812988,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/unsafe","score":0.09353212267160416,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfw","score":0.05748550593852997,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfl","score":0.03604661673307419,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]}]}],"publicTags":[{"namespace":"depicts","value":"person","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: person","countKey":"Depicts: person","searchPath":"/#tag=person&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"style","value":"low resolution","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: low resolution","countKey":"Style: low resolution","searchPath":"/#tag=low%20resolution&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"pixelated","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: pixelated","countKey":"Style: pixelated","searchPath":"/#tag=pixelated&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"portrait","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: portrait","countKey":"Style: portrait","searchPath":"/#tag=portrait&facet=style"},{"namespace":"mood","value":"neutral","namespaceLabel":"Mood","qualifiedValue":"Mood: neutral","countKey":"Mood: neutral","searchPath":"/#tag=neutral&facet=mood"},{"namespace":"color","value":"beige","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: beige","countKey":"Color: beige","searchPath":"/#tag=beige&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"dark brown","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: dark brown","countKey":"Color: dark brown","searchPath":"/#tag=dark%20brown&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"dark gray","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: dark gray","countKey":"Color: dark gray","searchPath":"/#tag=dark%20gray&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"light blue","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: light blue","countKey":"Color: light blue","searchPath":"/#tag=light%20blue&facet=color"},{"namespace":"source","value":"article","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: article","countKey":"article","searchPath":"/#tag=article"},{"namespace":"source","value":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","countKey":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race","searchPath":"/#tag=facebook%20lets%20advertisers%20exclude%20users%20by%20race"},{"namespace":"source","value":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","countKey":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race propublica","searchPath":"/#tag=facebook%20lets%20advertisers%20exclude%20users%20by%20race%20propublica"},{"namespace":"source","value":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race — propublica","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race — propublica","countKey":"facebook lets advertisers exclude users by race — propublica","searchPath":"/#tag=facebook%20lets%20advertisers%20exclude%20users%20by%20race%20%E2%80%94%20propublica"},{"namespace":"source","value":"julia angwin 1000x1000","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: julia angwin 1000x1000","countKey":"julia angwin 1000x1000","searchPath":"/#tag=julia%20angwin%201000x1000"}],"categoryPaths":{"person":"/tags/person","portrait":"/tags/portrait","neutral":"/tags/neutral","beige":"/tags/beige","dark brown":"/tags/dark-brown","dark gray":"/tags/dark-gray","light blue":"/tags/light-blue"}}