{"icon":{"sha256":"587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da","relativePath":"icons/58/587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da.jpg","extension":"jpg","mediaType":"image/jpeg","width":50,"height":50,"byteLength":1489,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"animationMetadataInspectedUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:38.3730180+00:00","scannerMetadataVersion":1,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:38.3730193+00:00"},"observations":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","sourceDisplayName":"Prospect live gallery www.propublica.org","sourceKind":"static-gallery","sourceType":"prospect-queue","rightsProfile":"Unreviewed prospect; preserve provenance and review rights before redistribution.","originalUrl":"https://www.propublica.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Justin-Elliott-close-crop.jpg?w=50","downloadUrl":"https://www.propublica.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Justin-Elliott-close-crop.jpg?w=50","pageUrl":"https://www.propublica.org/people/justin-elliott","title":"How Google and AI Nearly Made a Seasoned Reporter Spiral — ProPublica","altText":"","categoryPath":"article / google ai reporting / how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","status":"accepted","observedUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:38.3748965+00:00"}],"sourceTags":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"article","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"google ai reporting","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral — propublica","evidence":"observation · title · gallery · observation-title","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"justin elliott close crop","evidence":"observation · file-name · gallery · observation-download-url","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","tag":"justin elliott close crop","evidence":"observation · file-name · gallery · observation-original-url","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"reviews":[{"id":635060,"runId":63,"model":"qwen3-vl:30b","promptVariant":"wordwall-v1","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-smart","enrichmentMetadataVersion":5,"description":"A pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin, and a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt against a dark background.","rawJson":"{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da\",\"description\":\"A pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin, and a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt against a dark background.\",\"denseCaption\":\"The image is a pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin tone, and visible facial features including eyes, nose, and mouth. The person wears a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt. The background is a solid dark gray. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance with visible pixelation across all elements. The subject\\u0027s head is slightly tilted, and the face is oriented toward the left side of the frame. The lighting appears to be frontal, casting subtle shadows on the right side of the face. The image shows no visible text, symbols, or additional objects.\",\"wordwall\":[\"bald head\",\"light skin\",\"dark suit jacket\",\"white collared shirt\",\"dark gray background\",\"pixelated\",\"low resolution\",\"frontal lighting\",\"slight head tilt\",\"face oriented left\"],\"visibleText\":[],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"person\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[],\"colors\":[\"dark gray\",\"light skin\",\"dark\",\"white\"],\"style\":[\"pixelated\",\"low resolution\",\"close-up\"],\"composition\":[\"centered subject\",\"dark background\",\"frontal pose\"],\"mood\":[],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[\"pixelation obscures fine details\"],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[\"observation category (gallery): article\",\"observation category (gallery): google ai reporting\",\"observation category (gallery): how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica\",\"observation title (gallery): How Google and AI Nearly Made a Seasoned Reporter Spiral \\u2014 ProPublica\",\"observation file-name (gallery): Justin-Elliott-close-crop\"],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"Justin-Elliott\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[\"Justin-Elliott\"],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"bald person in dark suit\",\"pixelated close-up portrait\",\"white collared shirt dark background\",\"low resolution head shot\"],\"uncertainty\":[],\"aestheticStrengths\":[],\"aestheticWeaknesses\":[],\"tags\":[{\"tag\":\"person\",\"category\":\"subject\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: person\"},{\"tag\":\"pixelated\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: pixelated\"},{\"tag\":\"low resolution\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: low resolution\"},{\"tag\":\"close up\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: close-up\"},{\"tag\":\"dark gray\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: dark gray\"},{\"tag\":\"light skin\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: light skin\"},{\"tag\":\"dark\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: dark\"},{\"tag\":\"white\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: white\"}],\"rawModelResponse\":{\"icons\":[{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da\",\"description\":\"A pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin, and a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt against a dark background.\",\"denseCaption\":\"The image is a pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin tone, and visible facial features including eyes, nose, and mouth. The person wears a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt. The background is a solid dark gray. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance with visible pixelation across all elements. The subject\\u0027s head is slightly tilted, and the face is oriented toward the left side of the frame. The lighting appears to be frontal, casting subtle shadows on the right side of the face. The image shows no visible text, symbols, or additional objects.\",\"wordwall\":[\"bald head\",\"light skin\",\"dark suit jacket\",\"white collared shirt\",\"dark gray background\",\"pixelated\",\"low resolution\",\"frontal lighting\",\"slight head tilt\",\"face oriented left\"],\"visibleText\":[],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"person\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[],\"colors\":[\"dark gray\",\"light skin\",\"dark\",\"white\"],\"style\":[\"pixelated\",\"low resolution\",\"close-up\"],\"composition\":[\"centered subject\",\"dark background\",\"frontal pose\"],\"mood\":[],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[\"pixelation obscures fine details\"],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[\"observation category (gallery): article\",\"observation category (gallery): google ai reporting\",\"observation category (gallery): how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica\",\"observation title (gallery): How Google and AI Nearly Made a Seasoned Reporter Spiral \\u2014 ProPublica\",\"observation file-name (gallery): Justin-Elliott-close-crop\"],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"Justin-Elliott\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[\"Justin-Elliott\"],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"bald person in dark suit\",\"pixelated close-up portrait\",\"white collared shirt dark background\",\"low resolution head shot\"],\"tags\":[]}]}}","requestId":"647aff745ed2427caed93f61f9e6402d","promptTokens":1933,"responseTokens":600,"totalDurationNanoseconds":4053655100,"elapsedMilliseconds":9152,"reviewedUtc":"2026-08-21T06:24:10.9431351+00:00","tags":[{"tag":"dark","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: dark"},{"tag":"dark gray","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: dark gray"},{"tag":"light skin","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: light skin"},{"tag":"white","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: white"},{"tag":"close up","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: close-up"},{"tag":"low resolution","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: low resolution"},{"tag":"pixelated","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: pixelated"},{"tag":"person","category":"subject","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: person"}],"facts":{"colors":["dark gray","light skin","dark","white"],"composition":["centered subject","dark background","frontal pose"],"denseCaption":["The image is a pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin tone, and visible facial features including eyes, nose, and mouth. The person wears a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt. The background is a solid dark gray. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance with visible pixelation across all elements. The subject's head is slightly tilted, and the face is oriented toward the left side of the frame. The lighting appears to be frontal, casting subtle shadows on the right side of the face. The image shows no visible text, symbols, or additional objects."],"description":["A pixelated close-up of a person with a bald head, light skin, and a dark suit jacket over a white collared shirt against a dark background."],"metadataNotConfirmedByImage":["Justin-Elliott"],"metadataOnlyEntities":["Justin-Elliott"],"nonRedundantSearchPhrases":["bald person in dark suit","pixelated close-up portrait","white collared shirt dark background","low resolution head shot"],"preprocessingNotes":["pixelation obscures fine details"],"sourceMetadataInterpretation":["observation category (gallery): article","observation category (gallery): google ai reporting","observation category (gallery): how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","observation title (gallery): How Google and AI Nearly Made a Seasoned Reporter Spiral — ProPublica","observation file-name (gallery): Justin-Elliott-close-crop"],"style":["pixelated","low resolution","close-up"],"subjects":["person"],"wordwall":["bald head","light skin","dark suit jacket","white collared shirt","dark gray background","pixelated","low resolution","frontal lighting","slight head tilt","face oriented left"]}}],"duplicateCluster":{"groupId":1695869,"canonicalSha256":"587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da","duplicateBasis":"singleton","members":[{"sha256":"587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da","relativePath":"icons/58/587d03b089fae494163f1d930f0149772e4c59c43196786fd2de995a2601b3da.jpg","extension":"jpg","mediaType":"image/jpeg","width":50,"height":50,"byteLength":1489,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:38.3730193+00:00","matchBasis":"canonical","matchDistance":0,"qualityScore":86.322009,"isCanonical":true}]},"canonicalPath":"/icon/how-google-and-ai-nearly-made-a-seasoned-reporter-spiral-pro--587d03b089fae494","tagCounts":{},"typedEvidence":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004336,"value":"article","normalizedValue":"article","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004336,"value":"google ai reporting","normalizedValue":"google ai reporting","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004336,"value":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","normalizedValue":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004336,"value":"Justin-Elliott-close-crop","normalizedValue":"justin elliott close crop","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-original-url","disposition":"search","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004336,"value":"Justin-Elliott-close-crop","normalizedValue":"justin elliott close crop","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-download-url","disposition":"search","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-propublica-org-d2e5213ee413","observationId":1004336,"value":"How Google and AI Nearly Made a Seasoned Reporter Spiral — ProPublica","normalizedValue":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral — propublica","scope":"observation","kind":"title","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-title","disposition":"search","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"contentSafety":[{"id":766664,"runId":1255,"provider":"onnx","model":"OwenElliott/image-safety-classifier-s","task":"broad","inputMode":"image","preprocessMode":"four-even-frames;flatten-rgb192;stretch-224;triangle;nchw-rgb-u8","overallScore":0.07118069380521774,"overallLabel":"sfw","assessedUtc":"2026-08-01T21:34:40.5603875+00:00","scores":[{"category":"onnx/sfw","score":0.9288192391395569,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/unsafe","score":0.07118069380521774,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfl","score":0.04100756347179413,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfw","score":0.030173130333423615,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]}]}],"publicTags":[{"namespace":"depicts","value":"person","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: person","countKey":"Depicts: person","searchPath":"/#tag=person&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"style","value":"close up","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: close up","countKey":"Style: close up","searchPath":"/#tag=close%20up&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"low resolution","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: low resolution","countKey":"Style: low resolution","searchPath":"/#tag=low%20resolution&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"pixelated","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: pixelated","countKey":"Style: pixelated","searchPath":"/#tag=pixelated&facet=style"},{"namespace":"color","value":"dark","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: dark","countKey":"Color: dark","searchPath":"/#tag=dark&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"dark gray","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: dark gray","countKey":"Color: dark gray","searchPath":"/#tag=dark%20gray&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"light skin","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: light skin","countKey":"Color: light skin","searchPath":"/#tag=light%20skin&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"white","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: white","countKey":"Color: white","searchPath":"/#tag=white&facet=color"},{"namespace":"source","value":"article","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: article","countKey":"article","searchPath":"/#tag=article"},{"namespace":"source","value":"google ai reporting","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: google ai reporting","countKey":"google ai reporting","searchPath":"/#tag=google%20ai%20reporting"},{"namespace":"source","value":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","countKey":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral propublica","searchPath":"/#tag=how%20google%20and%20ai%20nearly%20made%20a%20seasoned%20reporter%20spiral%20propublica"},{"namespace":"source","value":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral — propublica","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral — propublica","countKey":"how google and ai nearly made a seasoned reporter spiral — propublica","searchPath":"/#tag=how%20google%20and%20ai%20nearly%20made%20a%20seasoned%20reporter%20spiral%20%E2%80%94%20propublica"},{"namespace":"source","value":"justin elliott close crop","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: justin elliott close crop","countKey":"justin elliott close crop","searchPath":"/#tag=justin%20elliott%20close%20crop"}],"categoryPaths":{"person":"/tags/person","close up":"/tags/close-up","dark":"/tags/dark","dark gray":"/tags/dark-gray","light skin":"/tags/light-skin","white":"/tags/white"}}