{"icon":{"sha256":"146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca","relativePath":"icons/14/146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca.jpg","extension":"jpg","mediaType":"image/jpeg","width":50,"height":50,"byteLength":8410,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"animationMetadataInspectedUtc":"2026-07-31T12:14:48.4495163+00:00","scannerMetadataVersion":1,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-07-31T12:14:48.4495171+00:00"},"observations":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","sourceDisplayName":"Prospect live gallery economix.blogs.nytimes.com","sourceKind":"static-gallery","sourceType":"prospect-queue","rightsProfile":"Unreviewed prospect; preserve provenance and review rights before redistribution.","originalUrl":"https://static01.nyt.com/images/2012/02/29/business/binyamin-appelbaum/binyamin-appelbaum-custom1.jpg","downloadUrl":"https://static01.nyt.com/images/2012/02/29/business/binyamin-appelbaum/binyamin-appelbaum-custom1.jpg","pageUrl":"http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/03/taking-aim-at-public-workers/","title":"Taking Aim at Public Workers - The New York Times","altText":"Binyamin Appelbaum","categoryPath":"2011 / 01 / 03 / taking aim at public workers / taking aim at public workers the new york times","status":"accepted","observedUtc":"2026-07-31T12:14:48.4504302+00:00"}],"sourceTags":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","tag":"binyamin appelbaum","evidence":"observation · alt-text · gallery · observation-alt-text","confidence":0.85,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","tag":"taking aim at public workers","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","tag":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","tag":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","evidence":"observation · title · gallery · observation-title","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","tag":"binyamin appelbaum custom1","evidence":"observation · file-name · gallery · observation-download-url","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","tag":"binyamin appelbaum custom1","evidence":"observation · file-name · gallery · observation-original-url","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"reviews":[{"id":634698,"runId":63,"model":"qwen3-vl:30b","promptVariant":"wordwall-v1","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-smart","enrichmentMetadataVersion":5,"description":"Pixelated close-up of a person wearing dark-framed glasses, light blue shirt, and dark jacket against a light background.","rawJson":"{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca\",\"description\":\"Pixelated close-up of a person wearing dark-framed glasses, light blue shirt, and dark jacket against a light background.\",\"denseCaption\":\"Pixelated close-up portrait of a person with light skin and short hair. The person wears dark-framed eyeglasses with black temples. Visible clothing includes a light blue shirt collar and a dark jacket. The background is a light, neutral color. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance with visible pixelation. The person\\u0027s mouth is closed, and the expression appears neutral. The right ear is partially visible with a reddish hue. The left ear is partially visible with a pinkish hue. The image is cropped to show the head and upper shoulders.\",\"wordwall\":[\"pixelated\",\"close-up\",\"dark-framed glasses\",\"light blue shirt\",\"dark jacket\",\"light background\",\"neutral expression\",\"right ear reddish\",\"left ear pinkish\",\"low-resolution\",\"blocky appearance\",\"head and shoulders\",\"short hair\",\"light skin\"],\"visibleText\":[],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"person\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[],\"colors\":[\"light blue\",\"dark\",\"light\",\"reddish\",\"pinkish\"],\"style\":[\"pixelated\",\"low-resolution\",\"close-up\"],\"composition\":[\"head and shoulders\",\"cropped\",\"neutral background\"],\"mood\":[\"neutral\"],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[\"image appears upscaled\"],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[\"observation alt-text (gallery): Binyamin Appelbaum\",\"observation category (gallery): taking aim at public workers\",\"observation category (gallery): taking aim at public workers the new york times\",\"observation title (gallery): Taking Aim at Public Workers - The New York Times\",\"observation file-name (gallery): binyamin-appelbaum-custom1\",\"observation category (gallery): 01\",\"observation category (gallery): 03\",\"observation category (gallery): 2011\"],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"Binyamin Appelbaum\",\"taking aim at public workers\",\"the new york times\",\"Taking Aim at Public Workers\",\"binyamin-appelbaum-custom1\",\"2011\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[\"Binyamin Appelbaum\"],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"pixelated person glasses light blue shirt\",\"close-up dark-framed glasses neutral expression\",\"light background blocky appearance\",\"right ear reddish left ear pinkish\"],\"uncertainty\":[],\"aestheticStrengths\":[],\"aestheticWeaknesses\":[],\"tags\":[{\"tag\":\"person\",\"category\":\"subject\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: person\"},{\"tag\":\"pixelated\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: pixelated\"},{\"tag\":\"low resolution\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: low-resolution\"},{\"tag\":\"close up\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: close-up\"},{\"tag\":\"neutral\",\"category\":\"mood\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: neutral\"},{\"tag\":\"light blue\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: light blue\"},{\"tag\":\"dark\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: dark\"},{\"tag\":\"light\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: light\"},{\"tag\":\"reddish\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: reddish\"},{\"tag\":\"pinkish\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: pinkish\"}],\"rawModelResponse\":{\"icons\":[{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca\",\"description\":\"Pixelated close-up of a person wearing dark-framed glasses, light blue shirt, and dark jacket against a light background.\",\"denseCaption\":\"Pixelated close-up portrait of a person with light skin and short hair. The person wears dark-framed eyeglasses with black temples. Visible clothing includes a light blue shirt collar and a dark jacket. The background is a light, neutral color. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance with visible pixelation. The person\\u0027s mouth is closed, and the expression appears neutral. The right ear is partially visible with a reddish hue. The left ear is partially visible with a pinkish hue. The image is cropped to show the head and upper shoulders.\",\"wordwall\":[\"pixelated\",\"close-up\",\"dark-framed glasses\",\"light blue shirt\",\"dark jacket\",\"light background\",\"neutral expression\",\"right ear reddish\",\"left ear pinkish\",\"low-resolution\",\"blocky appearance\",\"head and shoulders\",\"short hair\",\"light skin\"],\"visibleText\":[],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"person\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[],\"colors\":[\"light blue\",\"dark\",\"light\",\"reddish\",\"pinkish\"],\"style\":[\"pixelated\",\"low-resolution\",\"close-up\"],\"composition\":[\"head and shoulders\",\"cropped\",\"neutral background\"],\"mood\":[\"neutral\"],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[\"image appears upscaled\"],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[\"observation alt-text (gallery): Binyamin Appelbaum\",\"observation category (gallery): taking aim at public workers\",\"observation category (gallery): taking aim at public workers the new york times\",\"observation title (gallery): Taking Aim at Public Workers - The New York Times\",\"observation file-name (gallery): binyamin-appelbaum-custom1\",\"observation category (gallery): 01\",\"observation category (gallery): 03\",\"observation category (gallery): 2011\"],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"Binyamin Appelbaum\",\"taking aim at public workers\",\"the new york times\",\"Taking Aim at Public Workers\",\"binyamin-appelbaum-custom1\",\"2011\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[\"Binyamin Appelbaum\"],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"pixelated person glasses light blue shirt\",\"close-up dark-framed glasses neutral expression\",\"light background blocky appearance\",\"right ear reddish left ear pinkish\"],\"tags\":[]}]}}","requestId":"09dde7b239b04804b2e17f40c72e8ded","promptTokens":1951,"responseTokens":671,"totalDurationNanoseconds":3003855400,"elapsedMilliseconds":5406,"reviewedUtc":"2026-08-21T06:14:08.5682108+00:00","tags":[{"tag":"dark","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: dark"},{"tag":"light","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: light"},{"tag":"light blue","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: light blue"},{"tag":"pinkish","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: pinkish"},{"tag":"reddish","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: reddish"},{"tag":"neutral","category":"mood","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: neutral"},{"tag":"close up","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: close-up"},{"tag":"low resolution","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: low-resolution"},{"tag":"pixelated","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: pixelated"},{"tag":"person","category":"subject","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: person"}],"facts":{"colors":["light blue","dark","light","reddish","pinkish"],"composition":["head and shoulders","cropped","neutral background"],"denseCaption":["Pixelated close-up portrait of a person with light skin and short hair. The person wears dark-framed eyeglasses with black temples. Visible clothing includes a light blue shirt collar and a dark jacket. The background is a light, neutral color. The image has a low-resolution, blocky appearance with visible pixelation. The person's mouth is closed, and the expression appears neutral. The right ear is partially visible with a reddish hue. The left ear is partially visible with a pinkish hue. The image is cropped to show the head and upper shoulders."],"description":["Pixelated close-up of a person wearing dark-framed glasses, light blue shirt, and dark jacket against a light background."],"metadataNotConfirmedByImage":["Binyamin Appelbaum","taking aim at public workers","the new york times","binyamin-appelbaum-custom1","2011"],"metadataOnlyEntities":["Binyamin Appelbaum"],"mood":["neutral"],"nonRedundantSearchPhrases":["pixelated person glasses light blue shirt","close-up dark-framed glasses neutral expression","light background blocky appearance","right ear reddish left ear pinkish"],"preprocessingNotes":["image appears upscaled"],"sourceMetadataInterpretation":["observation alt-text (gallery): Binyamin Appelbaum","observation category (gallery): taking aim at public workers","observation category (gallery): taking aim at public workers the new york times","observation title (gallery): Taking Aim at Public Workers - The New York Times","observation file-name (gallery): binyamin-appelbaum-custom1","observation category (gallery): 01","observation category (gallery): 03","observation category (gallery): 2011"],"style":["pixelated","low-resolution","close-up"],"subjects":["person"],"wordwall":["pixelated","close-up","dark-framed glasses","light blue shirt","dark jacket","light background","neutral expression","right ear reddish","left ear pinkish","low-resolution","blocky appearance","head and shoulders","short hair","light skin"]}}],"duplicateCluster":{"groupId":1695521,"canonicalSha256":"146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca","duplicateBasis":"singleton","members":[{"sha256":"146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca","relativePath":"icons/14/146d88f2cfe5173d07da022bedababb485e301bb996f4b00938977ec67f6c4ca.jpg","extension":"jpg","mediaType":"image/jpeg","width":50,"height":50,"byteLength":8410,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-07-31T12:14:48.4495171+00:00","matchBasis":"canonical","matchDistance":0,"qualityScore":88.757423,"isCanonical":true}]},"canonicalPath":"/icon/taking-aim-at-public-workers-the-new-york-times--146d88f2cfe5173d","tagCounts":{},"typedEvidence":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"Binyamin Appelbaum","normalizedValue":"binyamin appelbaum","scope":"observation","kind":"alt-text","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-alt-text","disposition":"search","confidence":0.85,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"01","normalizedValue":"01","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"03","normalizedValue":"03","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"2011","normalizedValue":"2011","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"taking aim at public workers","normalizedValue":"taking aim at public workers","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","normalizedValue":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"binyamin-appelbaum-custom1","normalizedValue":"binyamin appelbaum custom1","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-original-url","disposition":"search","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"binyamin-appelbaum-custom1","normalizedValue":"binyamin appelbaum custom1","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-download-url","disposition":"search","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-economix-blogs-nytimes-com-1464d9efa326","observationId":1003690,"value":"Taking Aim at Public Workers - The New York Times","normalizedValue":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","scope":"observation","kind":"title","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-title","disposition":"search","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"contentSafety":[{"id":1086255,"runId":15988,"provider":"openai","model":"omni-moderation-latest","task":"narrow","inputMode":"image+text","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-4;static-256;animated-cell-256;gray192;nearest;png","overallFlagged":false,"overallScore":1.6865275398914433E-05,"overallLabel":"not-flagged","assessedUtc":"2026-09-03T19:22:37.6722676+00:00","scores":[{"category":"harassment","score":1.6865275398914433E-05,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.2},{"category":"sexual","score":1.1235328063870752E-05,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.09},{"category":"violence","score":1.0071400221737608E-05,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.15},{"category":"violence/graphic","score":5.829126566113866E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"illicit","score":3.8831109868779005E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.2},{"category":"self-harm","score":3.4808121961114687E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"hate","score":2.0462932829931794E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"self-harm/intent","score":1.9525885208642222E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"illicit/violent","score":1.1300808333434096E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"harassment/threatening","score":6.962256250138369E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"self-harm/instructions","score":3.288749065460498E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"sexual/minors","score":2.72647027069593E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"hate/threatening","score":6.681516500435412E-08,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.05}]},{"id":752414,"runId":1248,"provider":"onnx","model":"OwenElliott/image-safety-classifier-s","task":"broad","inputMode":"image","preprocessMode":"four-even-frames;flatten-rgb192;stretch-224;triangle;nchw-rgb-u8","overallScore":0.07211455702781677,"overallLabel":"sfw","assessedUtc":"2026-07-31T12:14:48.9314772+00:00","scores":[{"category":"onnx/sfw","score":0.9278854727745056,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/unsafe","score":0.07211455702781677,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfw","score":0.03845559433102608,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfl","score":0.033658962696790695,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]}]}],"publicTags":[{"namespace":"depicts","value":"person","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: person","countKey":"Depicts: person","searchPath":"/#tag=person&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"style","value":"close up","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: close up","countKey":"Style: close up","searchPath":"/#tag=close%20up&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"low resolution","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: low resolution","countKey":"Style: low resolution","searchPath":"/#tag=low%20resolution&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"pixelated","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: pixelated","countKey":"Style: pixelated","searchPath":"/#tag=pixelated&facet=style"},{"namespace":"mood","value":"neutral","namespaceLabel":"Mood","qualifiedValue":"Mood: neutral","countKey":"Mood: neutral","searchPath":"/#tag=neutral&facet=mood"},{"namespace":"color","value":"dark","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: dark","countKey":"Color: dark","searchPath":"/#tag=dark&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"light","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: light","countKey":"Color: light","searchPath":"/#tag=light&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"light blue","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: light blue","countKey":"Color: light blue","searchPath":"/#tag=light%20blue&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"pinkish","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: pinkish","countKey":"Color: pinkish","searchPath":"/#tag=pinkish&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"reddish","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: reddish","countKey":"Color: reddish","searchPath":"/#tag=reddish&facet=color"},{"namespace":"source","value":"binyamin appelbaum","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: binyamin appelbaum","countKey":"binyamin appelbaum","searchPath":"/#tag=binyamin%20appelbaum"},{"namespace":"source","value":"binyamin appelbaum custom1","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: binyamin appelbaum custom1","countKey":"binyamin appelbaum custom1","searchPath":"/#tag=binyamin%20appelbaum%20custom1"},{"namespace":"source","value":"taking aim at public workers","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: taking aim at public workers","countKey":"taking aim at public workers","searchPath":"/#tag=taking%20aim%20at%20public%20workers"},{"namespace":"source","value":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: taking aim at public workers the new york times","countKey":"taking aim at public workers the new york times","searchPath":"/#tag=taking%20aim%20at%20public%20workers%20the%20new%20york%20times"}],"categoryPaths":{"person":"/tags/person","close up":"/tags/close-up","neutral":"/tags/neutral","dark":"/tags/dark","light":"/tags/light","light blue":"/tags/light-blue","pinkish":"/tags/pinkish"}}