{"icon":{"sha256":"01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b","relativePath":"icons/01/01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b.img","extension":"img","mediaType":"image/png","width":48,"height":48,"byteLength":5788,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"animationMetadataInspectedUtc":"2026-07-27T20:38:48.8858690+00:00","scannerMetadataVersion":1,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-07-27T20:38:48.8858695+00:00"},"observations":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","sourceDisplayName":"Prospect live gallery www.realclimate.org","sourceKind":"static-gallery","sourceType":"prospect-queue","rightsProfile":"Unreviewed prospect; preserve provenance and review rights before redistribution.","originalUrl":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/65ed5ee9f296ae95461ca07530b347b3a4994cf4c98cb30f8964acd6944dac7e?s=48&d=blank&r=g","downloadUrl":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/65ed5ee9f296ae95461ca07530b347b3a4994cf4c98cb30f8964acd6944dac7e?s=48&d=blank&r=g","pageUrl":"http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2010/07/a-simple-recipe-for-ghe/index.php","title":"RealClimate: A simple recipe for GHE","altText":"","categoryPath":"index / archives / 2010 / 07 / a simple recipe for ghe / index / realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","status":"accepted","observedUtc":"2026-07-27T20:38:48.8869062+00:00"}],"sourceTags":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","tag":"a simple recipe for ghe","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","tag":"archives","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","tag":"realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","evidence":"observation · category · gallery · observation-category","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","tag":"realclimate: a simple recipe for ghe","evidence":"observation · title · gallery · observation-title","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"reviews":[{"id":630792,"runId":62,"model":"qwen3-vl:30b","promptVariant":"wordwall-v1","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-smart","enrichmentMetadataVersion":5,"description":"Green shield-shaped icon with white ship silhouette and banner reading 'RealClimate' below.","rawJson":"{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b\",\"description\":\"Green shield-shaped icon with white ship silhouette and banner reading \\u0027RealClimate\\u0027 below.\",\"denseCaption\":\"The image is a static digital graphic featuring a dark green, shield-shaped background. Centered on the shield is a stylized white ship silhouette with three masts and visible sails. Below the shield, a matching dark green ribbon banner displays partially legible text that appears to read \\u0027RealClimate\\u0027 in white lettering. The entire icon has pixelated edges typical of low-resolution digital art from early internet platforms.\",\"wordwall\":[\"green shield\",\"white ship silhouette\",\"three masts\",\"sailboat\",\"ribbon banner\",\"partially legible text\",\"pixelated edges\"],\"visibleText\":[\"RealClimate\"],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"ship\",\"banner\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[\"shield\",\"masts\",\"sails\",\"text\"],\"colors\":[\"dark green\",\"white\"],\"style\":[\"pixel art\",\"stencil-like\"],\"composition\":[\"central shield\",\"horizontal banner below\",\"symmetrical design\"],\"mood\":[],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"observation category (gallery): a simple recipe for ghe\",\"observation category (gallery): archives\",\"observation category (gallery): realclimate a simple recipe for ghe\",\"observation title (gallery): RealClimate: A simple recipe for GHE\",\"observation category (gallery): 07\",\"observation category (gallery): 2010\",\"observation category (gallery): index\",\"provenance source-name: Prospect live gallery www.realclimate.org\",\"provenance source-type: prospect-queue\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[\"RealClimate\"],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"green shield ship icon\",\"realclimate banner text\",\"white sailboat pixel art\",\"dark green shield with white ship\"],\"uncertainty\":[],\"aestheticStrengths\":[],\"aestheticWeaknesses\":[],\"tags\":[{\"tag\":\"ship\",\"category\":\"subject\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: ship\"},{\"tag\":\"banner\",\"category\":\"subject\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: banner\"},{\"tag\":\"shield\",\"category\":\"object\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: shield\"},{\"tag\":\"masts\",\"category\":\"object\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: masts\"},{\"tag\":\"sails\",\"category\":\"object\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: sails\"},{\"tag\":\"text\",\"category\":\"object\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: text\"},{\"tag\":\"pixel art\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: pixel art\"},{\"tag\":\"stencil like\",\"category\":\"style\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: stencil-like\"},{\"tag\":\"dark green\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: dark green\"},{\"tag\":\"white\",\"category\":\"color\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"evidence\":\"visible: white\"}],\"rawModelResponse\":{\"icons\":[{\"inputIndex\":0,\"sha256\":\"01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b\",\"description\":\"Green shield-shaped icon with white ship silhouette and banner reading \\u0027RealClimate\\u0027 below.\",\"denseCaption\":\"The image is a static digital graphic featuring a dark green, shield-shaped background. Centered on the shield is a stylized white ship silhouette with three masts and visible sails. Below the shield, a matching dark green ribbon banner displays partially legible text that appears to read \\u0027RealClimate\\u0027 in white lettering. The entire icon has pixelated edges typical of low-resolution digital art from early internet platforms.\",\"wordwall\":[\"green shield\",\"white ship silhouette\",\"three masts\",\"sailboat\",\"ribbon banner\",\"partially legible text\",\"pixelated edges\"],\"visibleText\":[\"RealClimate\"],\"uncertainText\":[],\"subjects\":[\"ship\",\"banner\"],\"actions\":[],\"objects\":[\"shield\",\"masts\",\"sails\",\"text\"],\"colors\":[\"dark green\",\"white\"],\"style\":[\"pixel art\",\"stencil-like\"],\"composition\":[\"central shield\",\"horizontal banner below\",\"symmetrical design\"],\"mood\":[],\"animation\":[],\"preprocessingNotes\":[],\"sourceMetadataInterpretation\":[],\"metadataSupportedByImage\":[],\"metadataNotConfirmedByImage\":[\"observation category (gallery): a simple recipe for ghe\",\"observation category (gallery): archives\",\"observation category (gallery): realclimate a simple recipe for ghe\",\"observation title (gallery): RealClimate: A simple recipe for GHE\",\"observation category (gallery): 07\",\"observation category (gallery): 2010\",\"observation category (gallery): index\",\"provenance source-name: Prospect live gallery www.realclimate.org\",\"provenance source-type: prospect-queue\"],\"metadataContradictedByImage\":[],\"visuallySupportedEntities\":[\"RealClimate\"],\"metadataOnlyEntities\":[],\"identityHypotheses\":[],\"namedEntities\":[],\"fandoms\":[],\"animationSummary\":\"\",\"nonRedundantSearchPhrases\":[\"green shield ship icon\",\"realclimate banner text\",\"white sailboat pixel art\",\"dark green shield with white ship\"],\"tags\":[]}]}}","requestId":"4eb6c2b02de440c3a3ae24c748f58b09","promptTokens":2018,"responseTokens":550,"totalDurationNanoseconds":3012340600,"elapsedMilliseconds":6353,"reviewedUtc":"2026-08-20T14:40:35.1827019+00:00","tags":[{"tag":"dark green","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: dark green"},{"tag":"white","category":"color","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: white"},{"tag":"masts","category":"object","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: masts"},{"tag":"sails","category":"object","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: sails"},{"tag":"shield","category":"object","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: shield"},{"tag":"text","category":"object","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: text"},{"tag":"pixel art","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: pixel art"},{"tag":"stencil like","category":"style","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: stencil-like"},{"tag":"banner","category":"subject","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: banner"},{"tag":"ship","category":"subject","confidence":0.8,"evidence":"visible: ship"}],"facts":{"colors":["dark green","white"],"composition":["central shield","horizontal banner below","symmetrical design"],"denseCaption":["The image is a static digital graphic featuring a dark green, shield-shaped background. Centered on the shield is a stylized white ship silhouette with three masts and visible sails. Below the shield, a matching dark green ribbon banner displays partially legible text that appears to read 'RealClimate' in white lettering. The entire icon has pixelated edges typical of low-resolution digital art from early internet platforms."],"description":["Green shield-shaped icon with white ship silhouette and banner reading 'RealClimate' below."],"metadataNotConfirmedByImage":["observation category (gallery): a simple recipe for ghe","observation category (gallery): archives","observation category (gallery): realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","observation title (gallery): RealClimate: A simple recipe for GHE","observation category (gallery): 07","observation category (gallery): 2010","observation category (gallery): index","provenance source-name: Prospect live gallery www.realclimate.org","provenance source-type: prospect-queue"],"nonRedundantSearchPhrases":["green shield ship icon","realclimate banner text","white sailboat pixel art","dark green shield with white ship"],"objects":["shield","masts","sails","text"],"style":["pixel art","stencil-like"],"subjects":["ship","banner"],"visibleText":["RealClimate"],"visuallySupportedEntities":["RealClimate"],"wordwall":["green shield","white ship silhouette","three masts","sailboat","ribbon banner","partially legible text","pixelated edges"]}}],"duplicateCluster":{"groupId":1691743,"canonicalSha256":"01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b","duplicateBasis":"singleton","members":[{"sha256":"01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b","relativePath":"icons/01/01d537a13932f57ce9bfdc9a0625a52cefd1b4618a13870a8128130f527f2c6b.img","extension":"img","mediaType":"image/png","width":48,"height":48,"byteLength":5788,"frameCount":1,"isAnimated":false,"firstSeenUtc":"2026-07-27T20:38:48.8858695+00:00","matchBasis":"canonical","matchDistance":0,"qualityScore":86.764226,"isCanonical":true}]},"canonicalPath":"/icon/realclimate-a-simple-recipe-for-ghe--01d537a13932f57c","tagCounts":{"archives":114},"typedEvidence":[{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"07","normalizedValue":"07","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"2010","normalizedValue":"2010","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"a simple recipe for ghe","normalizedValue":"a simple recipe for ghe","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"archives","normalizedValue":"archives","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"index","normalizedValue":"index","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","normalizedValue":"realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","scope":"observation","kind":"category","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-category","disposition":"search","confidence":0.8,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"65ed5ee9f296ae95461ca07530b347b3a4994cf4c98cb30f8964acd6944dac7e","normalizedValue":"65ed5ee9f296ae95461ca07530b347b3a4994cf4c98cb30f8964acd6944dac7e","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-original-url","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"65ed5ee9f296ae95461ca07530b347b3a4994cf4c98cb30f8964acd6944dac7e","normalizedValue":"65ed5ee9f296ae95461ca07530b347b3a4994cf4c98cb30f8964acd6944dac7e","scope":"observation","kind":"file-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-download-url","disposition":"hint","confidence":0.65,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","observationId":998213,"value":"RealClimate: A simple recipe for GHE","normalizedValue":"realclimate: a simple recipe for ghe","scope":"observation","kind":"title","authority":"gallery","origin":"observation-title","disposition":"search","confidence":0.7,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","value":"Prospect live gallery www.realclimate.org","normalizedValue":"prospect live gallery www.realclimate.org","scope":"provenance","kind":"source-name","authority":"gallery","origin":"source-display-name","disposition":"facet","confidence":1,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"},{"sourceId":"horizon-live-www-realclimate-org-1c2df82ec682","value":"prospect-queue","normalizedValue":"prospect queue","scope":"provenance","kind":"source-type","authority":"gallery","origin":"source-type","disposition":"facet","confidence":0.9,"methodKey":"typed-source-evidence-v2"}],"contentSafety":[{"id":958305,"runId":1319,"provider":"openai","model":"omni-moderation-latest","task":"narrow","inputMode":"image+text","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-4;static-256;animated-cell-256;gray192;nearest;png","overallFlagged":false,"overallScore":3.535625074174432E-06,"overallLabel":"not-flagged","assessedUtc":"2026-08-20T14:43:03.5830731+00:00","scores":[{"category":"enrichment/visual/violence","score":0.5,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"sexual","score":3.535625074174432E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.09},{"category":"harassment","score":1.6187581436151335E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.2},{"category":"illicit","score":1.3007128466476034E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.2},{"category":"violence/graphic","score":1.0129990980873922E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"hate","score":7.889262586245034E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"violence","score":7.183260399857925E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.15},{"category":"self-harm","score":3.6119830612765795E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"self-harm/intent","score":2.6425858208426533E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"illicit/violent","score":2.4824800371656586E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"sexual/minors","score":1.2878952156558146E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"harassment/threatening","score":1.101595360000069E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"self-harm/instructions","score":7.81148330637258E-08,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text","image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"hate/threatening","score":4.450850519411503E-08,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["text"],"threshold":0.05}]},{"id":716473,"runId":1201,"provider":"openai","model":"omni-moderation-latest","task":"narrow","inputMode":"image+text","preprocessMode":"contact-sheet-4;static-256;animated-cell-256;gray192;nearest;png","overallFlagged":false,"overallScore":0.0005553536215526795,"overallLabel":"not-flagged","assessedUtc":"2026-07-28T06:27:16.3371257+00:00","scores":[{"category":"violence","score":0.0005553536215526795,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["image"],"threshold":0.15},{"category":"sexual","score":6.986756664856784E-05,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["image"],"threshold":0.09},{"category":"self-harm","score":1.3982207564732913E-05,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"violence/graphic","score":1.1061159714638084E-05,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["image"],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"self-harm/intent","score":1.7502925788778209E-06,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"self-harm/instructions","score":9.972941593827283E-07,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":["image"],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"harassment","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.2},{"category":"harassment/threatening","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"hate","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"hate/threatening","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.05},{"category":"illicit","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.2},{"category":"illicit/violent","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.1},{"category":"sexual/minors","score":0,"flagged":false,"appliedInputTypes":[],"threshold":0.05}]},{"id":712008,"runId":1197,"provider":"onnx","model":"OwenElliott/image-safety-classifier-s","task":"broad","inputMode":"image","preprocessMode":"four-even-frames;flatten-rgb192;stretch-224;triangle;nchw-rgb-u8","overallScore":0.061568938195705414,"overallLabel":"sfw","assessedUtc":"2026-07-27T20:38:53.9293001+00:00","scores":[{"category":"onnx/sfw","score":0.9384310841560364,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/unsafe","score":0.061568938195705414,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfw","score":0.033106688410043716,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]},{"category":"onnx/nsfl","score":0.028462251648306847,"appliedInputTypes":["image"]}]}],"publicTags":[{"namespace":"depicts","value":"banner","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: banner","countKey":"Depicts: banner","searchPath":"/#tag=banner&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"depicts","value":"masts","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: masts","countKey":"Depicts: masts","searchPath":"/#tag=masts&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"depicts","value":"sails","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: sails","countKey":"Depicts: sails","searchPath":"/#tag=sails&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"depicts","value":"shield","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: shield","countKey":"Depicts: shield","searchPath":"/#tag=shield&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"depicts","value":"ship","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: ship","countKey":"Depicts: ship","searchPath":"/#tag=ship&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"depicts","value":"text","namespaceLabel":"Depicts","qualifiedValue":"Depicts: text","countKey":"Depicts: text","searchPath":"/#tag=text&facet=depicts"},{"namespace":"style","value":"pixel art","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: pixel art","countKey":"Style: pixel art","searchPath":"/#tag=pixel%20art&facet=style"},{"namespace":"style","value":"stencil like","namespaceLabel":"Style","qualifiedValue":"Style: stencil like","countKey":"Style: stencil like","searchPath":"/#tag=stencil%20like&facet=style"},{"namespace":"color","value":"dark green","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: dark green","countKey":"Color: dark green","searchPath":"/#tag=dark%20green&facet=color"},{"namespace":"color","value":"white","namespaceLabel":"Color","qualifiedValue":"Color: white","countKey":"Color: white","searchPath":"/#tag=white&facet=color"},{"namespace":"source","value":"a simple recipe for ghe","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: a simple recipe for ghe","countKey":"a simple recipe for ghe","searchPath":"/#tag=a%20simple%20recipe%20for%20ghe"},{"namespace":"source","value":"archives","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: archives","countKey":"archives","searchPath":"/#tag=archives"},{"namespace":"source","value":"realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","countKey":"realclimate a simple recipe for ghe","searchPath":"/#tag=realclimate%20a%20simple%20recipe%20for%20ghe"},{"namespace":"source","value":"realclimate: a simple recipe for ghe","namespaceLabel":"Source terms","qualifiedValue":"Source terms: realclimate: a simple recipe for ghe","countKey":"realclimate: a simple recipe for ghe","searchPath":"/#tag=realclimate%3A%20a%20simple%20recipe%20for%20ghe"}],"categoryPaths":{"banner":"/tags/banner","shield":"/tags/shield","text":"/tags/text","pixel art":"/tags/pixel-art","stencil like":"/tags/stencil-like","dark green":"/tags/dark-green","white":"/tags/white","archives":"/tags/archives"}}